Tomato Pie: A great way to get rid of all those tomatoes

I’ve gotten so many requests for this recipe that I’m offering it here.

My sister makes the low-cal version with low-fat cheese and mayo. This pie also makes great leftovers. And it’s a quick dish to take to a potluck. (Make two–they’ll love it!) 

You can use any kind of tomatoes. I like Romas because they aren’t as watery. I’ll bet orange and yellow tomatoes would be fabulous, too.

 The Publicity Hound’s Tomato Pie

1 regular or deep-dish piecrust in a tin (In frozen food section)

6 or 7 tomatoes, sliced, with skins on or off (I prefer Roms with skin removed and juice squeezed out)

From a half cup to a full cup of fresh basil

Oregano

Salt and pepper

Onion powder

Dill

1 cup mayo

1 cup sharp cheddar cheese, shredded

Let pie crust defrost for about 15 minutes. Prick bottom of crust with a fork. Bake in oven for 10 minutes at 400 degrees.

Remove from oven and let it cool. Place one layer of basil on bottom of crust so the juice doesn’t soak through. Add one layer of tomatoes. Sprinkle with onion powder, oregano, and salt and pepper. Cover with a layer of fresh basil.

Repeat until you’ve used all the tomatoes, and make sure tomatoes (not basil) are on the top. I usually end up with 3 layers in a deep-dish pie crust, or 2 to 3 layers in a regular crust.

Mix the mayo and shredded cheese in a bowl and spread on top of the pie, like icing. Sprinkle dill on top.

Bake in 350-degree oven for 30 minutes. Remove and let cool for about 20-30 minutes before eating so it isn’t runny. This is also good served at room temperature.

Please let me know in the comments below how you like it or if you’ve substituted any of the ingredients.

My Favorite Recipes
Comments (8)
Add Comment
  • Suzanne

    Sounds delish, can’t wait to try it!

  • Phyllis Dobbs

    I sure am glad you mentioned this in your newsletter. I missed your twitter post on it. I can’t wait to try it.

  • Kathy J, Washington Gardener Mag

    Oooh, could have used this for a graden club potluck picnic I attended last night – will keep this bookmarked for future events.

  • Nancy Bleeke

    Great! I now know what I making for an upcoming gardent party! Though my tomato plants aren’t nearly as productive as last year, there are plenty ripening right now!

    Thanks so much.

  • Christine Buffaloe

    I made this recipe last evening and although it was really tasty, I would have preferred in cold.

  • Joel Owen

    I love the smell and taste of Oregano when added in some recipes.~’-

  • Teri Blaschke

    This one’s pinned on my “meatless recipe” board so I can keep track of it. Can’t wait to try it.

    • Joan

      This pie is great for a potluck. Most important: Try to get all the juice out of the tomatoes before you put them in the pie or it will be really runny. I also like the tomatos without skins.